Instant Pot Creamy Tomato Chicken

As we live life with a stay at home order, during the time of coronavirus I’m getting both increasingly bored with my own cooking and increasingly creative. I’m struggling with the Middle’s quirky and picky eating habits and trying to throw dinner on the table with ingredients I have on-hand. Today we had a big hit with this creamy tomato chicken that I made in the Instant Pot.

Tomatoes, tomatoes, tomatoes

With the closure of so many restaurants, the local tomato farmers have found themselves with a surplus. We managed to snag 25 pounds of tomatoes for a whopping $5! I’ve posted the recipe using fire-roasted canned tomatoes, but today I didn’t have the canned variety. Instead I diced up 8 tomatoes and broiled them until a bit charred. They reduced down to about 4 cups and were perfect in my recipe.

The regular tomatoes were a bit underride, so I stuck them under the broiler for about 10 minutes. I also had a red pepper that was about done with life and I charred it as well. I removed the skin for this recipe. While you don’t need to remove the skin, it makes for a creamier sauce in the end. If you’re using jarred red peppers, the skin will already be removed. The red peppers were ready to come out a bit earlier than the tomatoes, so if you’re broiling fresh, check them often.

Cooking in the Time of Corona

What’s really great about this recipe, is that you can pretty easily swap out ingredients based on what you have fresh/pantry. I had fresh tomatoes, red pepper and rosemary on hand, but you can use the pantry equivalents on all of these. If you’ve scored some canned tomatoes, they’ll work equally as well. Have some fresh spinach on hand? Wilt that in. There are endless possibilities depending on what you have on hand and what your family enjoys.

The key to my creamy tomato chicken here is a unique flavor combination of tomato, rosemary and coriander. I’ve been pretty bored with my regular repetition of ingredients and stood there in the kitchen, sniffing all 3 together before I decided to throw them all in the pot. It was a risk, the Middle is notoriously picky. But the flavors came together wonderfully and the recipe was officially Middle Approved. He told me it tasted like a wonderful mix of tomato bisque soup and spaghetti sauce. We saved half the sauce to serve over pasta later this week.

How to Make Creamy Tomato Chicken

For this recipe, I borrowed heavily from my Instant Pot Butter Chicken recipe. I started with the same basic steps of softening the aromatics and then adding in the spices. Like my Butter Chicken, you cook the tomatoes and chicken under pressure and then later use an immersion blender to create a creamy sauce.

I like to serve my saucy, creamy tomato chicken over roasted cauliflower, but it also works wonderfully with pasta, rice, mashed potatoes and spaghetti squash.

Tools of the Trade

For this recipe the only extra “special” equipment you need are an Instant Pot and an immersion blender. For an immersion blender, I particularly like a set that includes a few different attachments. It’s nice to have a quick, lightweight way to process a small amount of food or quickly whip eggs. I also have a stand mixer, but sometimes you just don’t want to dirty up the big ol’ bowl for a small job. Get it here.